David stuckler, phd, mph, honmfph, frsa is a professor of political economy and sociology at university of oxford and research fellow of the london school of hygiene and tropical medicine. It shows that such economic tools are powerful, but they have ethical, policy, and technical limitations. I think neither has anything to contribute to either reducing chronic disease andor reducing. Chapter 8 responding to the global challenge of sick societies david stuckler and karen siegel end matter. Far from being the luxury the imf categorizes it as, public health spending is in fact necessary to the economic recovery of. It has its vocal critics but is widely held in academe along with its kin, moral relativity. In summary, sick societies is a highly ambitious and accessible book that succeeds in bringing together key material to make the case for accelerated action to address the global chronic disease epidemic. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, 2011 and basu medicineprevention research center, stanford univ. The body economic by david stuckler, sanjay basu kirkus. The body economic is the first, agendashaping, look at the human costs of financial crisis the culmination of ten years work by two pioneering researchers sanjay basu and david stucklerthe global financial crisis has had a seismic impact upon the wealth of nations.
I would highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in chronic disease, and as a key text for courses in global health and public health. This fascinating book takes you all over the world and deep into history. In brief, the book states that we have been sold a bill of goods on this issue. Chapter four identifi es different approaches to preventing and managing chronic diseases, while chapters five and six consider the power and politics in global health that have stymied an effective. However, through the sale and promotion of tobacco, alcohol, and ultraprocessed food and drink unhealthy commodities, transnational corporations are major drivers of global epidemics of ncds. Sick societies by david stuckler, 9780199574407, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The first three chapters explore the causes and consequences of chronic diseases on a global level. In his book sick societies robert edgerton challenges the notion that there are no valid criteria for evaluating cultures. Comprehensive strategies to reduce the burden of chronic diseases. Epianalysis sick societies is a highly ambitious and accessible book that succeeds in bringing together key material to make the case for accelerated action to address the global chronic disease epidemic. Sick societies and islamic nations darla martingorski may 2002 since william graham sumner first articulated it in 1906, cultural relativism has become axiomatic in the social sciences. In sick societies, edgerton questions the belief that cultures are naturally adaptive, pointing out instances of violence, misogyny, and social malaise. Cultural values that result in exploitation he claims are inferior to those that enhance peoples lives. Sick societies responding to the global challenge of chronic disease edited by david stuckler and karen siegel.
The snack food and beverage industrys tactics in context. Says edgerton, all societies are sick, but some are sicker than others. They published their findings in their 20 book the body economic. In sick societies, edgerton questions the belief that cultures are naturally adaptive, pointing out instances of violence, misogyny, and social malaise in precolonial indigenous societies. Sick societies argues that we are building environments that are poorly designed for our boides. May 21, 20 stuckler and basu gathered and analyzed huge sets of data on the effects that economic stringency has had on public health in recent history. I have contributed to several chapters of the book, and work closely with david stuckler, so i naturally agree with many of the book s conclusions. Professor stucklers book about the global chronicdisease epidemic, sick societies, was published by oxford university press in 2011. Causes and consequences first of all, a disclosure. Oct 20, 2011 sick societies is written in five main parts. Edgerton is less successful in the second half of the book, where repetition and circular reasoning impede his analysis of the broader collapse of societies. He is also an author of the body economic, published by penguin press in 20 and translated into over ten languages. Dec 17, 2011 sick societies by david stuckler, 9780199574407, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
He attacks the established tenets of relativism and adaptivism offering numerous examples of maladaptive practices. Sep 01, 2011 david stuckler, phd, mph, honmfph, frsa is a professor of political economy and sociology at university of oxford and research fellow of the london school of hygiene and tropical medicine. I would highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in chronic disease, especially to those working in this field, and as a key text for courses in global health and public health. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease 1st edition. Sick societies is a highly ambitious and accessible book that succeeds in bringing together key material to make the case for accelerated action to address the global chronic disease epidemic. His work has featured on covers of the new york times and the economist, among.
Noncommunicable diseases ncds have emerged as a substantial concern within the global health community due to their growing prevalence, the projected costs to societies of their impact and treatment, and recognition that they have traditionally been ignored relative to infectious disease in both public attention and donor funding. It is the first album after five years released by david t. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease. Hes the author of very many articles and coauthor of books including the body economic and sick societies. Jul 05, 2012 david stuckler, karen siegel, sick societies. Chastain under the name chastain and the first to feature the singer kate french, who replaced leather leone. In my opinion, it overeggs the cake in presenting the problem, and is naive and internally contradictory when approaching possible solutions. Eric van bemmel ive been talking about health, economics and society with david stuckler, professor of political economy and sociology at oxford university. The second part of the book identifies approaches for preventing and managing chronic diseases while the third part of the book considers the power and politics in global health that have. It will be a mandatory reader for courses in global health. I would highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in chronic disease, especially to those working in this field, and as a key text for. Evaluating the health burden of chronic diseases david stuckler, sanjay basu sick individuals, sick populations. His book about the global chronicdisease epidemic, sick societies, was published by oxford university press in 2011.
What role then should these industries have in ncd. That these are presented as the first two strategies for responding to the global challenge is extraordinary. Cultural relativism asserts, there is no scientific basis for. Edgertons sick societies forces us to question the basic assumptions of cultural relativism that have dominated anthropological thinking for most of the 20th century. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, oxford university press, 2011. Sick societies is a scholarly work by anthropologist robert edgerton, published in 1992. South africa karen siegel, david stuckler responding to the global challenge of sick societies david stuckler. His book about the global chronicdisease epidemic, sick societies. His thesis is that there are indeed sick societies and some are so maladaptive that they destroy themselves. Chronic diseasesheart disease, diabetes, lung disease, and common cancersclaim more than one out of every two lives worldwide. Maladaptive decisions, he argues, are made in all societies, and every society can be evaluated on a human measure of sickness or health. In his book, sick societies anthropologist edgerton suggests that we develop a scale for evaluating cultures on their quality of life much as we do for u. Stuckler d, siegel k, oconnor duffany k, kishore s, stevens d, basu s.
Professor david stuckler events at the university of. Stuckler and basu gathered and analyzed huge sets of data on the effects that economic stringency has had on public health in recent history. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, is now available from oxford university press, covering the social, political, and economic aspects of heart disease, diabetes, and leading causes of death worldwide. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, occupational medicine. Why corporate power is a public health priority the bmj. This book is the first to synthesize the growing evidencebase surrounding chronic disease, comprehensively addressing the prevention and control of chronic diseases from epidemiologic, economic, preventionmanagement, and political economy perspectives. Chronic diseases are the leading causes of death and disability worldwide. It has become controversial among some anthropologists for its deconstruction of cultural relativism. Stuckler senior research leaderoxford univ coauthor. But we have little sense of how it affects one of the most fundamental issues of all. Many anthropologists have chosen not to write about the darker side of life in folk societies. Stuckler and siegels book expertly pulls together the essential data and ideas needed to combat chronic diseases.
It is based on a narrow deterministic conception of society that pretty much all social ills are socially determined apart from ones that are due to biology to. Usually ships within 3 to 5 weeks see larger photo. There are some customs and social institutions in all societies that compromise human wellbeing. Examines the prevention and control of chronic diseases from epidemiologic, economic, preventionmanagement, and governance perspectives. Sick society is the sixth studio album by the american heavy metal band chastain, released in 1995 through leviathan records. This chapter details how economic perspectives can enlighten us on how best to respond to chronic diseases. The authors have succeeded in their vision to provide an analysis of the global challenge of chronic disease through the lens of what they term sick societies. The chapter begins by setting out the meaning of economic perspective and addressing its important drawbacks. How budgetcutting responses to recession produce increases in death rates and epidemiclike breakdowns in public health. The final summary section is entitled restoring the public health imagination which nuances the arguments made throughout the book for different audiences. Dannenberg, howard frumkin and richard editors, oxford university press, 2011. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, journal of public health on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Free shipping due to covid19, orders may be delayed.
Aug 21, 2012 the corporate play book, health, and democracy. China, india, mexico, and south africa \ karen siegel, david stuckler responding to the global challenge of sick societies \ david. Its main aim is to challenge the theory that folk societies and non western civilisations,lived in harmony with their enviroment,and that only modern western societies are the root of pollution,extinction,mass murder and social exclusion. Responding to the global challenge of chronic disease, occupational medicine, volume 62, issue 5, 5 july 2012. This is unquestionably one of the most important works in anthropological theory in the last half of the 20th century. Responding to the global challenge of health, wellbeing and sustainability. If you think the book s title is a tad dramatic, think again.
860 249 1075 1160 1334 778 564 416 136 722 810 1077 1509 1387 269 1058 11 663 1455 6 1116 586 403 280 455 766 1064 1367 1204 634 1209 72 1091 423 625 1192 290 873 832 1252 535 176 1013 490